Thewagnerwayhomes.com Search Results

$299,900

Enjoy the best of peaceful country living with this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom home situated on approximately 2 acres with a beautiful, park-like atmosphere. The spacious property offers plenty of room to create your own mini farm, garden, or outdoor retreat, with fruit trees already adding to its appeal. Located directly across the street from East Fork Lake State Park, outdoor enthusiasts will love having nature, hiking, fishing, boating, and recreation right nearby. At the same time, you're conveniently close to dining, shopping, and everyday amenities. If you're looking for a quiet place to enjoy privacy, open space, and the outdoors while still being close to conveniences, this property is a must-see!

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1893743 MLS

Enjoy the best of peaceful country living with this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom home situated on approximately 2 acres with a beautiful, park-like atmosphere. The spacious property offers plenty of room to create your own mini farm, garden, or outdoor retreat, with fruit trees already adding to its appeal. Located directly across the street from East Fork Lake State Park, outdoor enthusiasts will love having nature, hiking, fishing, boating, and recreation right nearby. At the same time, you're conveniently close to dining, shopping, and everyday amenities. If you're looking for a quiet place to enjoy privacy, open space, and the outdoors while still being close to conveniences, this property is a must-see!

2571 Williamsburg Bantam Rd, Bethel

$40,000

Short drive to local restaurants and entertainment! All Utilities located at the street! Parcel ID # 360320.176 Easter Valley Lot 75

1892906 MLS

Short drive to local restaurants and entertainment! All Utilities located at the street! Parcel ID # 360320.176 Easter Valley Lot 75

413 Grace Way, Bethel

$50,000

All utilities are already located at the street! Short drive to lots of local restaurants and entertainment! Parcel ID # 360320.179 Easter Valley Lot 78

1892900 MLS

All utilities are already located at the street! Short drive to lots of local restaurants and entertainment! Parcel ID # 360320.179 Easter Valley Lot 78

649 Lily Way, Bethel

$800,000

Commercial Automotive Service Facility 4320 sq ft with some equipment included. Excellent opportunity to acquire a well establish commercial service garage. Building is a 80 x 54 with a functional layout designed for automotive service operations. The building features 4 service bays, office space, and a restroom. The property also offers approximately 9,800 square feet of parking lot area with fencing. Property offers two parcels with an additional driveway access.

1892534 MLS

Commercial Automotive Service Facility 4320 sq ft with some equipment included. Excellent opportunity to acquire a well establish commercial service garage. Building is a 80 x 54 with a functional layout designed for automotive service operations. The building features 4 service bays, office space, and a restroom. The property also offers approximately 9,800 square feet of parking lot area with fencing. Property offers two parcels with an additional driveway access.

336 S Main Street, Bethel

$179,900

Set in the heart of Bethel, 519 S Union Street offers an inviting, move-in-ready home with a comfortable layout and plenty of room to enjoy inside and out. The bright, refreshed interior features updated flooring, neutral finishes and an abundance of natural light. Two bedrooms, a spacious living room and full bath are complemented by a generously sized kitchen that opens to an oversized dining area creating plenty of space for everyday living and entertaining. Outside, a deep backyard offers room to relax, play, garden or create your ideal outdoor setup. Whether you're searching for your first home, looking to downsize or adding to an investment portfolio, this home delivers a great combination of space, simplicity and value.

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1891934 MLS

Set in the heart of Bethel, 519 S Union Street offers an inviting, move-in-ready home with a comfortable layout and plenty of room to enjoy inside and out. The bright, refreshed interior features updated flooring, neutral finishes and an abundance of natural light. Two bedrooms, a spacious living room and full bath are complemented by a generously sized kitchen that opens to an oversized dining area creating plenty of space for everyday living and entertaining. Outside, a deep backyard offers room to relax, play, garden or create your ideal outdoor setup. Whether you're searching for your first home, looking to downsize or adding to an investment portfolio, this home delivers a great combination of space, simplicity and value.

519 S Union Street, Bethel

$165,000

2-bedroom home featuring a garage and carport. Home offers newer laminate flooring, fresh interior paint, and an updated kitchen. Nice-sized yard provides space for outdoor activities or gardening. Includes a dedicated laundry room for added convenience. A solid option for someone looking to add their own finishing touches.

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1890668 MLS

2-bedroom home featuring a garage and carport. Home offers newer laminate flooring, fresh interior paint, and an updated kitchen. Nice-sized yard provides space for outdoor activities or gardening. Includes a dedicated laundry room for added convenience. A solid option for someone looking to add their own finishing touches.

124 Clark Street, Bethel

$358,500

Over 7 acres of versatile land in the Bethel-Tate School District offering endless possibilities for farming, recreation, livestock, or creating your own private retreat. The property features a stocked pond, a 24x38 pole barn, and a 40x62 barn with loft, providing exceptional space for equipment, animals, storage, hobbies, or a workshop. The 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers over 2,500 square feet with potential for a 4th bedroom and plenty of opportunity to make the space your own. Enjoy the privacy and flexibility of acreage while remaining conveniently located with easy access to OH 125.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1890836 MLS

Over 7 acres of versatile land in the Bethel-Tate School District offering endless possibilities for farming, recreation, livestock, or creating your own private retreat. The property features a stocked pond, a 24x38 pole barn, and a 40x62 barn with loft, providing exceptional space for equipment, animals, storage, hobbies, or a workshop. The 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers over 2,500 square feet with potential for a 4th bedroom and plenty of opportunity to make the space your own. Enjoy the privacy and flexibility of acreage while remaining conveniently located with easy access to OH 125.

2147 Bethel Maple Road, Bethel

$249,900

High potential in 2 story homestead which boasts over 2700 square feet per the auditor. This residence has high quality old world charm and is in need of some refreshing from a new owner with an eye for older homes. A large great room addition was added to the original victorian structure expanding the original homestead by over 50%. Large bedrooms on the second floor and extended height ceilings provide for an airy feel on the second level. Two car detached garage and 3 additional parking spaces on the asphalt driveway provides ample space for vehicles. A carriage house adjacent to the property is also being sold and may be purchased separately. Come see one of the gems in the Village of Bethel!!!

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1891113 MLS

High potential in 2 story homestead which boasts over 2700 square feet per the auditor. This residence has high quality old world charm and is in need of some refreshing from a new owner with an eye for older homes. A large great room addition was added to the original victorian structure expanding the original homestead by over 50%. Large bedrooms on the second floor and extended height ceilings provide for an airy feel on the second level. Two car detached garage and 3 additional parking spaces on the asphalt driveway provides ample space for vehicles. A carriage house adjacent to the property is also being sold and may be purchased separately. Come see one of the gems in the Village of Bethel!!!

231 S Main Street, Bethel

$595,000

Two commercial parcels totaling 10.77 acres. All utilities available. Prime location for business or residential development with direct access to St Rt 125. Permitted Use: Office, commercial, multifamily housing, light industrial. Site was originally laid out and partially developed for multi family and strip mall units by previous owners. Zoning: B-2 General Business (Village of Bethel).

1890592 MLS

Two commercial parcels totaling 10.77 acres. All utilities available. Prime location for business or residential development with direct access to St Rt 125. Permitted Use: Office, commercial, multifamily housing, light industrial. Site was originally laid out and partially developed for multi family and strip mall units by previous owners. Zoning: B-2 General Business (Village of Bethel).

720 W Plane Street, Bethel

$375,000

Exceptional commercial investment opportunity featuring a 9,800+ sq ft building with numerous updates and a strong income-producing history. Long-term tenants are already in place, providing immediate rental income, while additional space offers significant potential to expand revenue and maximize the property's earning potential. The restored second level adds character and versatility, while the vintage elevator has been restored and is now fully operational, creating a unique feature rarely found in commercial properties. The flexible upstairs layout can accommodate a variety of commercial uses, making this property ideal for investors, owner-users, or businesses looking to expand. Positioned in a prime location with excellent visibility and convenient access, this property offers the ideal combination of current income, historic character, and future upside. A unique opportunity to add a flexible, income-producing asset to your portfolio.

1889446 MLS

Exceptional commercial investment opportunity featuring a 9,800+ sq ft building with numerous updates and a strong income-producing history. Long-term tenants are already in place, providing immediate rental income, while additional space offers significant potential to expand revenue and maximize the property's earning potential. The restored second level adds character and versatility, while the vintage elevator has been restored and is now fully operational, creating a unique feature rarely found in commercial properties. The flexible upstairs layout can accommodate a variety of commercial uses, making this property ideal for investors, owner-users, or businesses looking to expand. Positioned in a prime location with excellent visibility and convenient access, this property offers the ideal combination of current income, historic character, and future upside. A unique opportunity to add a flexible, income-producing asset to your portfolio.

222 W Plane Street, Bethel

307 S Main Street, Bethel

$?

Sells at live auction on August 29, 2026 10 AM. Well located

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1888142 MLS

Sells at live auction on August 29, 2026 10 AM. Well located

310 E Plane Street, Bethel

$369,500

NEARLY 14 ACRES + POND + CREEK + OVERSIZED GARAGE! This 3-bedroom home offers the space, privacy, and possibilities buyers are looking for. Enjoy a stocked pond with dock, a creek running through the property, and nearly 14 acres perfect for recreation, animals, hobbies, or simply getting away from it all. Inside, the home offers 1 full bath with plumbing already in place for a future second bath. Recent updates include new siding and a new front door, while the roof and HVAC are approximately 6 years old. The oversized detached garage provides exceptional space for vehicles, equipment, storage, or a workshop. Located in the Bethel-Tate Local School District with convenient access to OH-125 and situated in a USDA-qualifying area, offering potential zero-down financing for qualified buyers. Acreage, water features, garage space, and room to grow this one checks a lot of boxes!

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1887658 MLS

NEARLY 14 ACRES + POND + CREEK + OVERSIZED GARAGE! This 3-bedroom home offers the space, privacy, and possibilities buyers are looking for. Enjoy a stocked pond with dock, a creek running through the property, and nearly 14 acres perfect for recreation, animals, hobbies, or simply getting away from it all. Inside, the home offers 1 full bath with plumbing already in place for a future second bath. Recent updates include new siding and a new front door, while the roof and HVAC are approximately 6 years old. The oversized detached garage provides exceptional space for vehicles, equipment, storage, or a workshop. Located in the Bethel-Tate Local School District with convenient access to OH-125 and situated in a USDA-qualifying area, offering potential zero-down financing for qualified buyers. Acreage, water features, garage space, and room to grow this one checks a lot of boxes!

3796 Starling Road, Bethel

$199,500

Welcome home to 417 Davis Ln. This well maintained brick ranch sits on a quaint street in the heart of Bethel. Move in ready with all of the major updates handled- New furnace 2026, New AC 2026, New water heater 2020, New Roof 2016. A few of the charming features include original hardwood floors, arched doorways, a lovely wood-burning fireplace, and an established peach tree! Handicapped accessible with a roll-up front ramp, wide doorways, one level living & laundry, and grab bars in shower/tub. A small yard means minimal grass to cut- perfect for those with a busy lifestyle or those approaching retirement. Small fenced in section off of laundry room would work well for a pet or child play space. Spacious one car garage with overhead storage and a shed for housing all of the extras. A must see for those seeking low maintenance living in a quiet area. Property is USDA, VA, and FHA eligible!

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1887171 MLS

Welcome home to 417 Davis Ln. This well maintained brick ranch sits on a quaint street in the heart of Bethel. Move in ready with all of the major updates handled- New furnace 2026, New AC 2026, New water heater 2020, New Roof 2016. A few of the charming features include original hardwood floors, arched doorways, a lovely wood-burning fireplace, and an established peach tree! Handicapped accessible with a roll-up front ramp, wide doorways, one level living & laundry, and grab bars in shower/tub. A small yard means minimal grass to cut- perfect for those with a busy lifestyle or those approaching retirement. Small fenced in section off of laundry room would work well for a pet or child play space. Spacious one car garage with overhead storage and a shed for housing all of the extras. A must see for those seeking low maintenance living in a quiet area. Property is USDA, VA, and FHA eligible!

417 Davis Lane, Bethel

$119,000

Back on market no fault to seller. Charming all-stone cottage in the heart of Bethel offering 2 bedrooms and 1 bath behind a striking hand-laid stone exterior and covered front porch. Inside you'll find fresh neutral paint, wood-look flooring throughout, a functional eat-in kitchen with white and sage-green cabinetry, and a spacious backyard with mature trees and a storage shed offering plenty of potential. A great opportunity for an investor or hands-on buyer looking to add their own touch to a home with genuine character.

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1887047 MLS

Back on market no fault to seller. Charming all-stone cottage in the heart of Bethel offering 2 bedrooms and 1 bath behind a striking hand-laid stone exterior and covered front porch. Inside you'll find fresh neutral paint, wood-look flooring throughout, a functional eat-in kitchen with white and sage-green cabinetry, and a spacious backyard with mature trees and a storage shed offering plenty of potential. A great opportunity for an investor or hands-on buyer looking to add their own touch to a home with genuine character.

415 S Union Street, Bethel

$185,000

Don't miss this unique investment property located in one of Bethel's highest-traffic areas. This versatile offering includes one apartment and one home, providing multiple opportunities for income generation. Lease both buildings to create a strong investment portfolio, With outstanding visibility, easy access, and a prime location in Bethel, this property offers exceptional potential for investors. This property is full of opportunity. Back on market due to no fault of its own.

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1887041 MLS

Don't miss this unique investment property located in one of Bethel's highest-traffic areas. This versatile offering includes one apartment and one home, providing multiple opportunities for income generation. Lease both buildings to create a strong investment portfolio, With outstanding visibility, easy access, and a prime location in Bethel, this property offers exceptional potential for investors. This property is full of opportunity. Back on market due to no fault of its own.

113 Plane, Bethel

$274,900

Three Bedroom and two full bath ranch home with 2 car garage. Open floor plan. Hi-efficiency furnace. Built new in 2011! Private backyard on cul de sac street! Agent related to seller.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1882373 MLS

Three Bedroom and two full bath ranch home with 2 car garage. Open floor plan. Hi-efficiency furnace. Built new in 2011! Private backyard on cul de sac street! Agent related to seller.

318 Faith Way, Bethel

$134,900

Multi-unit commercial building in the heart of town. This property has the ability to be used as 4 units. Efficiency apartment, garage space, and open retail/multi-purpose space. Past commercial space has included a karate studio and floral shop. Apartment and garage space are currently tenant occupied and producing income.

1875711 MLS

Multi-unit commercial building in the heart of town. This property has the ability to be used as 4 units. Efficiency apartment, garage space, and open retail/multi-purpose space. Past commercial space has included a karate studio and floral shop. Apartment and garage space are currently tenant occupied and producing income.

201 S Main Street, Bethel

$299,900

Prime 1.5-acre commercial opportunity with frontage on OH 125 in Tate Township! This high-visibility property offers strong traffic exposure and an excellent location for a variety of commercial uses. Situated in a growing area with convenient access to surrounding communities and major roadways, the possibilities for development are extensive. Whether you're looking to establish a new business, expand your current operation, or invest in future growth, this property offers the location and visibility to make it happen. Seller is entertaining all offers, creating an excellent opportunity to bring your vision to this highly traveled commercial corridor.

1872340 MLS

Prime 1.5-acre commercial opportunity with frontage on OH 125 in Tate Township! This high-visibility property offers strong traffic exposure and an excellent location for a variety of commercial uses. Situated in a growing area with convenient access to surrounding communities and major roadways, the possibilities for development are extensive. Whether you're looking to establish a new business, expand your current operation, or invest in future growth, this property offers the location and visibility to make it happen. Seller is entertaining all offers, creating an excellent opportunity to bring your vision to this highly traveled commercial corridor.

2 St Rt 125, Bethel